Exogenous and endogenous
criminological factors in
crimes committed by inmates
of the National Penitentiary
Institute of Andahuaylas.
Factores criminológicos exógenos y
endógenos en los delitos cometidos
por las internas del Instituto Nacional
Penitenciario de Andahuaylas
Gerardo Quispe Auccalla
Law Degree, Universidad San Antonio Abad del
Cusco, Andahuaylas, Peru,
Professor of Criminology and Criminalistics at the
Universidad Tecnológica de los Andes.
gquispea@utea.edu.pe, https://orcid.org/0000-
0002-3162-7426
Javier José Arista Valdivia
Master in Communication and Marketing,
Universidad Católica de Santa María.
Docent jarista@ucsm.edu.pe , https://orcid.org/0000-
0002-8213-6053
Abstract
The objective of this article is to show the findings of a
study carried out in the Andahuaylas penitentiary, on
the endogenous and exogenous criminological factors
that led women to commit the crime from their own
perspective and try to call for social reflection. As a
researcher one of the functions is to look for the cause
of the problems by asking questions, posing
hypotheses and explaining the phenomena studied.
Like all research, not all answers are flattering; Some
questions asked fall short of the dimension of the
Imaginario Social
Publishing entity
University of Guayaquil -
REDICME (reg-red-18-0061)
e-ISSN: 2737-6362
July - December 2021 Vol. 4-2-2021
http://revista-
imaginariosocial.com/index.php/es/index
Receipt: February 15, 2021
Acceptance: April 25, 2021
100-110
101
problem, of the investigation. This research is descriptive, it studies a problem that is
not clearly defined, so it is carried out to better understand it, but without providing
conclusive results, the instrument used has the validity and reliability required for said
study, a dichotomous survey with closed questions was used.
Keywords: factors, exogenous, endogenous, internal.
Resumen
El objetivo de este artículo es mostrar los hallazgos de estudio realizado en el centro
penitenciario de Andahuaylas, sobre los factores criminológicos endógenos y exógenos
que llevaron a las mujeres a cometer el delito desde su propia perspectiva y tratar de
llamar a una reflexión social. Como investigador una de las funciones es buscar la causa
de los problemas a través de formularse preguntas plantearse hipótesis y explicar los
fenómenos estudiados. Como toda investigación no todas las respuestas son
lisonjeras; algunas preguntas formuladas quedan cortas, frente a la dimensión del
problema, de la investigación. Dicha investigación, es descriptiva estudia un problema
que no está claramente definido, por las ciencias criminológicas, por lo que, se lleva a
cabo para comprenderlo mejor, pero sin proporcionar resultados concluyentes, ya que
la ciencia social es relativa, el instrumento utilizado tiene la validez y confiabilidad
requerido para dicho estudio se usó una encuesta dicotómica con preguntas cerradas.
Palabras clave: factores, exógenos, endógenos, internas.
Introduction
Criminology is a scientific discipline, a set of objective, verifiable knowledge obtained
through observation, experimentation, which covers and studies in an interdisciplinary
way the criminality, which aims to explain its principles, causes, formulation,
verification and study of crime, crime, the offender, the victim and the means of social
control. Criminological factors are those external and internal causes that influence or
influenced some part of the offender's life, which led him to commit this criminal act,
therefore, each offender and there are different motivations that influenced and led
him to commit the criminal act.
102
Undoubtedly criminology, as a science has tried to solve with the help of different
sciences, the origin of crime, the causes of criminal behavior, these different sciences,
which support we could mention the most important, among them, we have the law
par excellence Penology, Forensic Medicine, Statistics, Anthropology and Psychology.
"Criminology: A science that studies in a scientific way, the antisocial or criminal
individual, antisocial behavior, crime and criminality, in turn also seeks to provide
prevention and treatment solutions through different criminological policies", (Hikal
W. , 2011)
Criminology is the synthetic, casual, explanatory, natural and cultural science of
antisocial behaviors. (Quiroz, 1965, p. 3)
The woman, in the criminal world exists, to study this problem, is to open the way for
future research, although there is an index, low approximately 5 thousand women in
all the prisons of Peru, according to INEI figures, this figure is from the first national
penitentiary census, carried out in 2016, these at present, is not in accordance with the
reality of now. It must be taken into account, about what the United Nations
Organization mentions to us, which defines gender identity, as the internal and
individual experience of gender, as, each person experiences it, which could
correspond or not, with the sex assigned, at birth, including the personal experience of
the body and other expressions of gender, such as speech, clothing or manners.
Therefore, this statistic would not be counted.
With reference to the above mentioned, there is a serious problem about the situation
of the prisons where women live, a problem with little knowledge in the negative
penitentiary world, where there are anti-values, corruption, without fulfilling one of
the most important purposes of the penalty, which is the resocialization, in turn
depriving many rights, not only that of the custodial sentence, but rights to other
related rights of women and their children, she being the most important pillar of the
family, in some cases violating the superior right of the child; Even though she is
allowed to be with the minor in the penitentiary institute, it does not have the
conditions and deprives the child of socialization with other children.
103
The low level of female delinquency, in relation to that of men, is universally recognized
by all criminologists. Therefore, we can infer that women are always and everywhere
less likely than men to commit criminal acts. "Perhaps this is what justifies that, in
Latin America until very recent times, and even today, studies on female delinquency
are no more than a mere appendix, when they exist, to studies on general male
criminology". (Sanchez, 2004, p. 2).
When talking about women and their situation in prisons, we have to mention the very
important social function that women have as pregnant women or mothers, who are
abandoned by their partners and must resort to solution mechanisms and face
different problems and difficulties, which, starting from the socioeconomic, go deep
into the inner structure of their own personality and transcend the sphere of
academics. (Escobar, Parra, & Flores, 2020).
We have to talk about violence and the rejection of violence against women, has been
one of the main banners of struggle of the feminist movement, which is why it is an
issue that has echoed for hundreds of years in the ears of humanity, however, it is in
recent decades that has gained more strength and value as a means of vindication for
women, who in their constant effort, despite the biting silencing, have been
consolidating a social movement, which has been positioned worldwide, from different
areas of society. As a constant vindication, this struggle finds spaces to contribute to
the implementation of reforms and promote the denunciation, disapproval and
rejection of abuse and other forms of violence. (Castiblanco & Perassi, 2020).
Despite the fact that we are in the XXI century, the problems that occur on violence
against women do not stop, and become the dispute of one of the greatest historical
setbacks of everyday life. Therefore, there are several studies that, at different times,
feminists from all continents, have been raised against gender violence in all its forms.
(Castro Rozo, 2020)
It should not be forgotten that currently women have been violated of many rights and
deprived in prisons, not only punished with imprisonment, but also as a unique being,
which gives a very important link between her, her children and family, other rights
104
are violated, therefore, the sanction is more drastic in women, mainly those who have
families.
To make an, analysis of physical, psychological, sexual and economic violence in both
socioeconomic strata, finding a higher incidence of economic violence, in marginal
urban areas and sexual violence in urban areas. physical, psychological, sexual and
economic violence, is evidenced in geographical areas in other research concluded that,
there is a higher incidence of economic violence, in urban-marginal areas, and sexual
violence, in urban areas. (Gómez, 2019)
We must necessarily differentiate the very narrow margin between the notion of
aggressiveness and violence: while the first emanates as a natural process, among
living organisms, the effect of aggressiveness, with the stimulation of drives, such as
eating, sexual drive, satisfaction of physiological needs and, consequently, of survival,
as its cause. Aggressiveness, expressed in the need constrained in stimuli, is not present
the role of the conscious and of the possibility, but only of the action. (Hernandez,
2019)
The social fact, encompasses different realities and phenomena, among them religion,
marriage, work, power, social or collective representations, family, violence and, of
course, education; knowing and differentiating these realities will give us guidelines to
distinguish criminological factors. (Prieto Galindo, Gómez, Acero, & Castro Nemocón)
It is worth mentioning that other countries are already applying the gender
mainstreaming approach (GTA) and that it must be included within the normative
parameters; it is unavoidable to include a regulation with gender mainstreaming in
which there is true gender equality between men and women. (Xochithl, 2019) The
Gender Mainstreaming Approach (GTA), as a new parameter, comes from
international positions that have effectively recognized the requirement of gender
openness to strengthen structural relations between men and women.
According to the author Wael Hikal, he mentions that
The criminological factors, endogenous and exogenous, in the investigation are the
elements related to the conduct of the subject, which guides us in the concept of
knowledge, the reasons for antisocial behavior, endogenous factors can be somatic and
105
psychic, and exogenous factors can be physical, family and social, the environment in
which the subject is surrounded.
In this context, studying the exogenous and endogenous criminological factors that
have an impact on female inmates, it is of utmost importance to know the perception
of how the women felt the factors that led them to commit the crime. It should be noted
that we must distinguish between exogenous and endogenous factors.
Classification of endogenous criminogenic factors.
Endogenous factors are those that are born with the individual and act towards the
external environment, producing certain results. There are authors who establish a
relationship between the activity of the human organism and antisocial behaviors.
Endogenous causes are those that are shown in the body, and refer to changes in the
body structure and functioning, such as anomalies or defects and body diseases,
hereditary or acquired, anatomical anomalies, as referred by one of the greatest
exponents of criminology, Cesare Lombroso, who held the theory of the born criminal,
which made a reference to those individuals, who were pre destined to commit
criminal acts, within which they possessed characteristics such as abnormal skull
height, arms and larger ears, sunken forehead, etc. (Gamboa et al., 2019), (Hikal,
2017).
Exogenous factors are those that refer to the natural environment (climate, rain, heat,
cold, cold, humidity, etc.), and the artificial environments formed by human beings
(the neighborhood, housing, the media, etc.). The natural and artificial environment
constitutes a constant stimulus to which the subject interacts continuously. (Gamboa
et al., 2019) (Hikal W. S., 2017)
Mario Bunge, rightly contributes his knowledge applicable to the subject, from which
it is determined that, when referring to endogenous and exogenous factors, and putting
the letter "and" between them means that: "the terms are closely linked, and that they
will give as a total, what results from the sum of both".
They are endogenous, those that are born with the subject and act towards the external
environment producing certain results. There is a relationship between the activity of
the organism and antisocial behaviors. For Solís Quiroga: "They are endogenous
106
causes, the somatic ones, those that are manifested in the body, they refer to the
changes in the structure and corporal functioning, as well as the anomalies or defects
and corporal, hereditary or acquired diseases, also particularities in their
development". (Solís Quiroga, 1985, p. 77).
Materials and Methods
This article is framed in the field of study of criminology and criminal law, with a
quantitative, descriptive, transversal methodology. It highlights certain characteristics
of the inmates of the National Penitentiary Institute of Andahuaylas, being the
population under study the total of 23 inmates.
Population 23 inmates, who answered the questionnaire on endogenous and
exogenous factors. The instrument used was a survey with a total of 34 items.
Results
In the process of obtaining data, a structured and integrated survey was carried out,
made up of 34 questions that include endogenous and exogenous factors. To this end,
the study analyzes these criminological factors of the inmates of the penitentiary
institute who committed different crimes, the most frequent being the crime of illicit
drug trafficking, and it is worth noting that a good percentage of these crimes were
committed by people outside or foreign to the department of Apurimac.
First operative moment of the investigation.
The structured survey was carried out and the closed survey was applied to the inmates
of the penitentiary institute, which lasted approximately 10 minutes. The results are
shown in the following tables. It can be seen that 47.8% of the women surveyed have
a partner or spouse, while 52.2% of the women do not have a partner, spouse or
cohabitant. Of the women surveyed, 4.3% had committed a previous crime, while
95.7% of the women had not committed a previous crime. 21.7% of the women
surveyed were influenced to commit a crime by other people, while 78.3% of the
women answered no. 65.2% of the women surveyed believe that the economic factor
influenced them to commit a crime and 34.8% said no. 21.7% of the women surveyed
believe that society influenced them to commit a crime, while 78.3% of the women
surveyed believe that society influenced them to commit a crime, 34.8% of the women
107
surveyed believe that bad company influenced them to commit the crime, while 65.2%
of the women said no. 39.1% of the women surveyed have ever suffered violence, while
60.9% of the women said no. 26.1% of the women surveyed have never suffered
violence, while 26.1% of the women surveyed have never suffered violence, while 26.1%
of the women surveyed have never suffered violence, 26.1% of the women surveyed
believe that violence against women causes them to commit crimes, while 73.9% of the
women said no. It can be observed that 13% of the women surveyed said that they were
pregnant when they committed the crime, while 87% of the women said no, 8.7% of
the women surveyed indicated that they were menstruating at the time they committed
the crime, while 91.3% of the women said they were not, 39.1% of the women surveyed
had been victims of abandonment, while 60.9% of the women surveyed had been
victims of abandonment, while 69.6% of the women surveyed had been victims of
psychological mistreatment, 4.3% of the women surveyed have been victims of rape,
while 17.4% of the women have no children, 100% of the women surveyed were not
menstruating at the time of the crime, 13% of the women surveyed have never suffered
from psychological abuse, 56.6% of the women surveyed suffered psychological abuse
at some time in their infancy, childhood or adolescence, suffered psychological abuse,
have children, while 43.5% of women marked no, it can be observed that 60.9% of the
women surveyed suffered physical abuse at some time in their infancy, childhood or
adolescence, have children, while 43.5% of women marked no, it can be observed that
60.9% of the women surveyed suffered psychological abuse at some time in their
infancy, childhood or adolescence, It is possible to observe that 100% of the women
surveyed have and responded that they would not allow themselves to be influenced
by a group or gang to commit crimes. 26.1% of the women surveyed have suffered some
type of abuse with loss of consciousness, while 73.9% of women said they had not,
while 73.9% of women said they had not,9% of the women marked no, 100% of the
women surveyed said that they would not be influenced by a program, talk show or
television series to commit a crime, 34.8% of the women surveyed were abandoned by
their parents or relatives at some time when they were children or adolescents, while
34.8% of the women marked no.
Discussion
108
That, having come, to determine, exogenous and endogenous factors, to the inmates
of the Penitentiary Center of Andahuaylas, are immersed in the commission of the
crime, in its different modalities, in its greater part, in the commission of the crime,
against the Public Health, in its modality of illicit drug trafficking, the Peruvian State
always, has pretended to eradicate this scourge of humanity, through the rules,
translated into criminal sanctions, but it was never the object of analysis of a very
adequate criminal policy, for example, "the implementation in the educational system,
from initial education, regular basic education, secondary education and higher
education, the ergological science and participation of professionals for the
psychological aspects in the educational area".(Olivera Diaz, 1987, p. 126). In our
country, the study of the vocation to work was left aside, and consequently, the
improvement and education of the female gender was postponed, proof of this, we do
not have a greater number of professionals, at all levels and modalities, the female
gender, aspects which are extremely important in the discussion of endogenous and
exogenous factors, These aspects are extremely important in the discussion of
endogenous and exogenous factors in the commission of crime in the female gender
and the implementation of new criminal policy systems, as inculcation to the vocation
to work, in order to eradicate the female gender in the commission of crime in its
different modalities, since they are pillars of the moral formation of children, within
the maternal home.
In order to analyze the exogenous and endogenous factors in the commission of the
crime in the inmates as a suitable criminal policy, the gender ideology and the
constitution should be applied; we do not refer in the gender ideology to feminist ideals
or thoughts but to parity and equality of opportunities in education, work, etc. But this
is not only a job for society but also for the state, which should not abandon the family
as the supreme goal of the state through social programs, education, job opportunities
and support in all aspects of the life of women and the family.
It has been observed that it is necessary to investigate more deeply into each crime
committed and its relationship with endogenous and exogenous factors, since we have
been able to identify certain factors and relationships in some women in relation to
the crime committed.
109
With the implementation of an adequate criminal policy, based on the application of
ergological science, we would be combating this problem, which is the commission of
crime by women, as it is a very little studied issue; In the commission of the crime, in
its different modalities, arranged in our Penal Code, since, the implantation of the
sanctioning, punitive, reparative and/or compensatory norms, are not adequate
Criminal policies, but a method, adequate according to their social status, should be
implanted, to eradicate the commission of the crime of the feminine gender.
It was determined that the exogenous and endogenous factors arise in the absence of
the presence of the state and the abandonment of families, since they can be carried
out through social promoters to collect the operating mode of family activities in order
to guide family activities and implement social control (which is required by criminal
law).
At the same time, with the participation of social promoters, the participant observer
method should be put into practice, as offered by criminology as a method to combat
crime in its different modalities.
References
Castiblanco, Y. A., & Perassi, M. P. (24 de 8 de 2020). La imagen del género:
comunicación gráfica y representacióndela mujer. Perspectivas, 18, 20-34.
doi:Recuperado a partir de
https://revistas.uniminuto.edu/index.php/Pers/article/view/2285
Castro Rozo, S. P. (8 de Julio de 2020). Comunicación-cultura política en los debates
del empoderamiento feminista. Centro Sur, 4(2), 314-336.
doi:https://doi.org/10.37955/cs.v4i2.85
Escobar , H., Parra, P. A., & Flores, M. P. (4 de Enero - Junio de 2020). Estudiantes
embarazadas: Retos de la Universidad Técnica Estatal de Quevedo para evitar
formas de violencia contra la mujer. Centro Sur, 4(1), 1-15.
doi:https://doi.org/10.37955/cs.v4i1.39
Gamboa, M., Barros, L., & Barros, C. (2019). Childhood Aggressiveness, Learning
110
and Self-Regulation in Primary Students. Luz. Revista Electrónica Trimestral de
La Universidad de Holguín, 53(9), 1689–1699.
https://luz.uho.edu.cu/index.php/luz/article/view/743/637
Gómez, D. E. (2 de Enero-junio de 2019). Políticas públicas en violencia de género en
el Centro de Emergencia Mujer. Socialium revista científica de Ciencias Sociales,
3(2), 12-21. doi:https://doi.org/10.31876/sl.v3i2.9
Hernandez, d. l. (Enero de 2019). La violencia: reflexiones para el debate.
UNIVERSCIENCIA, 17(50), 87-91. Obtenido de
http://revista.soyuo.mx/index.php/uc/article/view/107/136
Hikal, W. (2011). Introduccion al estudio de la Criminologia. Mexico: Porrua.
Hikal, W. S. (Marzo de 2017). Revision teorica a la genesis de la conducta criminal.
Revista Electronica de Psicologia Iztacala, 20(1), 186-209. Obtenido de
https://www.iztacala.unam.mx/carreras/psicologia/psiclin/vol20num1/Vol20
No1Art11.pdf
Olivera Diaz, G. (1987). Criminología Peruana. Lima: Ojeda.
Prieto Galindo, W. A., Gómez, N. M., Acero, M. L., & Castro Nemocón, A. M. (s.f.).
Educación y justicia social:desafios y expectativas de la educación inclusiva en el
contexto del estado social de derecho. Sinergias Educativas, 5(2), 287-304.
doi:10.37954/se.v5i2.138
Quiroz, A. (1965). Evolucion de la Criminologia. Mexico: Derecho Penal
Contemporaneo.
Sanchez, M. (2004). La mujer en la teoria criminologica. Mexico: La ventana.
Xochithl, G. R. (Febrero de 2019). Equidad de género en la Facultad de Derecho
“Abogado Ponciano Arriaga Leija” de la Universidad Autónoma de San Luis
Potosí, México. Espirales, 3(25), 47-58. doi:
https://doi.org/10.31876/re.v3i25.439